Dan & Phil Part 57: Pinky and the Brain

Our two favourite full time internet nerds who never go outside!
Locked
User avatar
Catallena
classy cat lady
classy cat lady
Posts: 3212
Joined: Wed Mar 30, 2016 6:56 pm
Location: The Netherlands

Can we make a collective effort to grill Dan about his supposed talk with Felix next liveshow? Because I still don't believe it happened, especially considering there were other people besides Marzia, PJ and Sophie there as well. I don't want Dan to wave this off with a 'yeah we had a good talk' and that'll be it. D&P are both masters of ignoring topics they don't wanna talk about but we can try right?

lol at instant karma coming through and D&P having to deal with Emma Blackery in a private setting. :rofl:
000dia000 wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 1:44 pm
dancy wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 1:28 pm Oh boy...
Image
I'm going to be honest, anybody who doesn't stan deppy probably just added them to the blacklist. I'm saying what they're doing is bad, but they're certainly toeing the line. If they don't have a large fanbase, or at least Dan saying "I'm going to talk to him" then this would probably be a much more controversial pic. They aren't in my bad books, nor am I saying they should be, but we do kind of give them a lot of slack, while a lot of people (even here) otherwise hate a lot of other youtubers in this pic, or youtubers who associate with pewdiepie-like people. I'm kind of interested how this will play out, in the next couple of days. In the future. One bad association doesn't equal the entirety of a person's character, but you know how things can be blown out of proportion.

Will, "they associate and support pewdiepie" be added to their list on one of those "your fav is problematic" tumblr pages?
Oh definitely. I expect his picture to get dug up by antis (mostly ex-phannies who still keep tabs on them) when Felix inevitably fucks up yet again.
drearyquery wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 6:07 pm if you’re someone who thinks them hanging out with Felix is bad do you think dan or Phil is “worse”? dan supports stuff and says he’s an activist but I know some people think it’s just to get brownie points or act ‘woke’ bc he doesn’t follow through. On the other hand Phil goes to the same parties and interacts with the same people but doesn’t outwardly talk about anything controversial. Do y’all think dan’s slight hypocrisy makes it worse? or is it better because he still condones some things.

I feel like this has probably been brought up before but with the new photo and discussions I’m curious to see what people think.
Interesting question. I don't think either are worse or better than each other, but Dan brought the heat on himself by making that statement that he'd talk to Felix when it's quite clear that it was said for selfish reasons because he was going to that birthday party either way and not because he genuinely wanted to do the right thing. On top of how 'woke' he often presents himself to be, that's why people are directing the majority of their disappointment to him. As for Phil, his avoidance of any sort of confrontation is annoying but well known. I don't expect anything good or bad from him regarding certain issues so it's like 'I could get mad at this but what did I expect?' for me.
coffeepenguin wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 6:08 pm Hi guys, great spooky design :skeleton: :thumb: so, uhm, many great things have happened lately (Dan’s video :love2: ), but I didn't feel like posting. In the end, as always, I couldn't stay away from a controversial topic, so now I want to weigh in on the whole Felix situation (under spoiler, because controversial opinion, but don’t crucify me yet, I'm not planning of defending Felix, ok?) :?
I am generally a bit bothered by the “deppy MUST ditch Felix” discourse, but I wasn't sure how to present my argument against it and real life just offered a great example, so here you go.

Yesterday, I went to a friend’s birthday party. She’s not racist or homophobic or anything-else-phobic, I’m pretty sure of it, I met her during my Master’s on human rights, she knows I'm gay, she’s never ever (to my knowledge) said anything offensive to any minority, she was friends with another one of our classmates who was black AND gay AND Muslim, you know, and plenty of other reasons why she’s not a Bad Person. However, her boyfriend of three years, whom she’s planning on marrying, is islamophobic and talks about it a lot (mind you, he doesn't think he is, he just thinks Islam is incompatible with respecting human rights and dignity and somehow finds this way of thinking ok).

Now, some of our mutual friends stopped socialising with my friend and her boyfriend because they find his opinions wrong and talking to him about it uncomfortable. I didn't, although I, too, completely disagree with him and do not particularly enjoy discussing the issue with him. Why? Because I don’t think it’ll accomplish anything if I just cut him from my life, I’ll just lose my friend because it’s difficult to find occasions to meet as it is, we’re both pretty busy people. Instead, I prefer to visit them when it’s someone’s birthday or for the New Year and when he starts on his favourite topic, I calmly offer my counter-arguments to what he’s saying. I honestly think this is a much better way to make the world a better and safer place than just to cut people from your life (side note: it’s all great to say “find better friends” but when you live in a foreign country and sometimes work 24/7, it’s not so easy, I literally found myself completely alone for last year’s winter holidays and I couldn't leave the country to go back to my family, if it were not for this friend, I would spend the New Year’s Eve on youtube in my pjs with a bottle of vodka. Not that it in any way relates to deppy, but I just wanted to complain and Dan and Phil have their own reasons for why it can be difficult to find friends). Now, of course, nobody among us is famous or anything, like all these youtubers, but the guy I'm talking about works as a teacher in primary school, for instance, so he has a pretty big role in shaping young minds. Do I find it dangerous? Maybe, a little bit. But what’s the alternative? Are we talking about legally banning people from jobs or the society in general because of their opinions, however bad they are? I hope not. Then, people, of course, have every right, as a private citizen, not to engage with somebody they don’t like. Me, I choose to engage because otherwise nothing will change, people you cut from your life will just become bitter and will even maybe turn to worse things. I'm not saying this is exactly what Deppy are thinking, but treating them as complete garbage just because they continue to socialize with someone like Felix, when they made it very clear they disagree with him and don’t give him any promotion (not that he needs it, I’ll grant you that), seems to me as a somewhat immature reaction and one that doesn't really help with the bringing forward progress on social issues we all care about. (My friend, btw, clearly disagrees with her boyfriend, too, and although she doesn't really publicly go into debates with him, when he starts talking about Muslims, she’s always trying to subtly shut him down or make excuses, and we've talked with her about this issue being the only thing that bothers her in an otherwise perfect guy and how she hopes he’ll change because they’re talking about it in private.)

love&peace to everyone <3 (I'm not trying to be condescending, btw, I sincerely love everyone on this forum and hope y'all are having a great day)
Here's my problem with anecdotes like this because I've thought about this a bit the past few days. This post is not only directed at you btw it's partly a draft of something generic I wrote a few days ago so it's also a bit of a mess (I tried my best to save it and form it into something coherent).

You and your racist or any other kind of -ist or -phobic friend are probably equals. Your friend does not have significant power over one of the world's biggest online platforms and the relatively small community that comes with it that is important to your career. Your friend does not silence your criticism by manipulating you with the power they have over that community and essentially forcing you to publicly apologize for not being blindly supportive (yeah yeah I don't actually have any actual proof of manipulation but what happend with Jackscepticeye's criticism still gives me the creeps) and a bad friend. Your friend is not the literal internet poster boy of the young alt-right and actively pandering to that part of his fanbase, fucking up the platform yo depend on for everyone by being one of the major causes of the aforementioned adpocalypse which is hitting minorities particularly hard.

Friends who are equals can go into legitimate discussion with each other. But the people around Felix are not his equals (no not even Marzia and someone still needs to explain to me why people keep giving her a pass and assume she will call him out when we have no proof she's at all educated about this and it not being beneficial for her to do so) and he damn well knows it because he keeps fucking up and giving out non apologies because he knows he doesn't really have peers or superiors who can make him feel consequences.

There's another layer to this. When we interact with our problematic friends we are not public people. Not to force D&P into the the roles of 24/7 role models because that's unfair, but they do have a significant influence over young people of all races, ethnicities, sexualities and genders. And by interacting with other public figures they give out a message. D&P who are generally seen as decent people despite their many privileges hanging with Felix makes it easier for other to excuse him. And in this case making the interaction public was even their choice so it's not like one can completely defend this with 'it was private!' or anything.

@ijustwantdeath I love your posts on this subject! <3
Image
Twitter *•.(★).•* Tumblr
Grey
lady door
Posts: 181
Joined: Fri May 05, 2017 8:17 pm
Location: Canada

Logged in on my computer to see the spooky banner and it did not disappoint. I appreciate how much work people do with this forum, it's amazing. <3

Speaking of things I want D&P to talk about: I would be very interested in hearing Dan explain to us why he is okay with hanging out with Pdp. It seems to completely go against the things he says lately. I'm tempted to pay actual money to ask him on younow except I'm guessing there's a 0% chance he'd answer it, lol. I'm so curious about his thought process in justifying it.

I totally get not wanting to disown your entire friend group because of one person's stupid opinions or whatever, and I also get that if you keep in contact with the person you can provide counter-arguments to them. And I don't think people should only be friends with people who have the same opinions as them. I was originally on-the-fence about this issue for that reason. Especially because I have loads of coworkers with unsavoury opinions and I never correct them because I don't want drama. But then I read the comments under a few of his videos and I realized…

This guy's whole shtick is being a racist, sexist, homophobic, et al. asshole. It's how he got 50M subscribers. He knows EXACTLY what he's doing and he's very successful at it. So it's not like he is an otherwise great guy with a few uninformed opinions. Dan has joked about it ("everyone's problematic dad") as if it's funny, and he has claimed he'll talk about it with Pdp as if Pdp is just uninformed. Pdp is not uninformed. He's doing it entirely on purpose (and making bank from it). So to me, Dan's comments about it seem to minimizing the issue a lot.

(And why am I only talking about Dan and not Phil? IDK, man. Phil's there too. I guess I give Dan more flack for it because he is vocal about his opinions whereas Phil isn't).
I'm having a stress.
plath
sofa crease
Posts: 91
Joined: Mon May 01, 2017 8:42 pm

Personally I wouldn't be able to be friends with someone who held such different views from my own. I'm not sure what we'd have in common and I wouldn't feel comfortable around them. I've met people before who have on closer acquaintence revealed themselves to have "edgy" (aka racist, fatphobic, misogynistic etc.) humour and I've just noped on out of there because life is too short to surround yourself with nasty people. The situation is a little more complicated when you're coworkers and have to interact in a more professional environment, but the same sentiment still stands - you can be professional while also maintaining your distance.

However, I think it's hard to try to extrapolate our own personal experiences to this situation because (as far as I know...?) no-one here is a public figure with a large platform and hugely visible social interactions. I think that alittledizzy's comment is a very nuanced take and one I pretty much agree with 100%.

I do think it's interesting (and perhaps a little unfair) that the main criticism seems to be leveled at Dan, while Phil is also there. Dan is at least trying(YMMV on how performative that is) whereas Phil never sticks his head above the parapets. It kind of reminds me of the way that as soon as a female celebrity identifies as a feminist, she's often torn to shreds in social justice circles - whatever she's doing, she's doing wrong, or she's not doing enough, or she's doing too much. SJ discourse often seems to spend more time criticizing actual feminists and allies than people who are flagrantly and blatantly misogynistic or directly opposed to social justice concepts. It's crazy! Are we trying to effect change here, or just score points on doing things "correctly"? Basically, I think it's unfair to castigate Dan for this while letting Phil off the hook. Dan at least has acknowledged that there is a problem. Phil's silence is deafening.
nope.
User avatar
Birdie
blobfish
Posts: 650
Joined: Sat Nov 05, 2016 8:22 pm
Pronouns: they/them

If deppy are anything it’s non-confrontational. They’ve never taken part in or reacted to any kind of drama and I think to them this is what this is. I’m not happy about it and it does make me question them to be honest because right now I can’t be sure what they really think. I like to believe they both realise what Felix did was terrible and that it’s not just a little slip-up but I can’t be sure because they don’t talk about this kind of thing. So right now there are two options: Either they do believe what they say about equality and stuff like that and just don’t want to get mixed up in controversy or they just say “woke” stuff because everyone’s doing it right now and their private thoughts on some things are quite different. We don’t know. This is a problem for me atm because I used to think “They wouldn’t do this harmful thing because they’re usually quite woke and educated on these subjects” but now I’m wondering if they really are and if they’re not… does it mean they would do the harmful thing?

I never expected them to drop Felix altogether. Not just because they’re friends but also because of how powerful he is in the Youtube world. But I honestly thought they wouldn’t interact with him out in the open anymore. I was wrong there, I guess, and I don’t know how I feel about this atm. Because it’s true: Sweeping a racist’s racism under the rug is pretty much enabling behaviour. It sends the message that what Felix did wasn’t that bad to millions of younger viewers who look up to deppy. And I really don’t like that. And I don’t think you can really compare this situation to having problematic friends yourselves. Deciding to stay friends with someone despite them being problematic is one thing but y’all aren’t broadcasting this friendship to thousands of impressionable young viewers. That’s the part I have a problem with. Not them being friends with him in private, that’s their personal business.

This obviously doesn't make them bad people. It's a tough situation to handle since it will have to happen with millions of people watching and I guess not saying anything is the most non-confrontational route to take and that's very much what they've always done. I'm just slightly disappointed is all.
User avatar
Ewok
rainbow nerd
Posts: 233
Joined: Thu Jul 27, 2017 12:32 am
Pronouns: she/her
Location: USA

Brack wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 7:14 pm Hi!
Long time lurker emerging. Been stalking you all since GG days. Was afraid to post anything for ages, and don't think I really want to join in the current discussion :hmmm:
But
Probably now is not a good time to let you all know I ended up stood next to deppy at a crossroad earlier today and they are v cute when they are candid.
Also because I like to feed the idb pigeons, they only had phil's galaxy backpack between them :shrug:
(I kid because ofc there isn't much you'd need for an overnight stay lol. But figured after The Spain Suitcase, might as well)

Anyway sorry for the random post (confused excitement got to me) but hi.
Welcome, Brack :platonic:

Thanks for the cute dip & pip fodder. :blackheart: The domestic image this painted in my head is exactly what I needed today. All I want is world peace and to cuddle up in a blanket with some coffee, lmao.
(Not that the felix/deppy discourse isn't important, but sometimes it's just so heavy on my heart to think about the world we live in. Boo, I'm so emo today)

I don't even know what I'd do if I spotted them out and about in a casual setting, even though in my mind that's when I'd prefer to meet them (rather than a M&G). I'd probably just stare and be a bit starstruck, now that I'm thinking about it. Did you manage to say hi?
»»-————𝓯𝓵𝓸𝓹𝓹𝔂 𝓭𝓲𝓷𝓰 𝓭𝓸𝓷𝓰————-««
User avatar
alittledizzy
actual demon phannie
actual demon phannie
Posts: 7101
Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 3:09 pm
Pronouns: she/her

Ewok wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 8:02 pm
Brack wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 7:14 pm Hi!
Long time lurker emerging. Been stalking you all since GG days. Was afraid to post anything for ages, and don't think I really want to join in the current discussion :hmmm:
But
Probably now is not a good time to let you all know I ended up stood next to deppy at a crossroad earlier today and they are v cute when they are candid.
Also because I like to feed the idb pigeons, they only had phil's galaxy backpack between them :shrug:
(I kid because ofc there isn't much you'd need for an overnight stay lol. But figured after The Spain Suitcase, might as well)

Anyway sorry for the random post (confused excitement got to me) but hi.
Welcome, Brack :platonic:

Thanks for the cute dip & pip fodder. :blackheart: The domestic image this painted in my head is exactly what I needed today. All I want is world peace and to cuddle up in a blanket with some coffee, lmao.
(Not that the felix/deppy discourse isn't important, but sometimes it's just so heavy on my heart to think about the world we live in. Boo, I'm so emo today)

I don't even know what I'd do if I spotted them out and about in a casual setting, even though in my mind that's when I'd prefer to meet them (rather than a M&G). I'd probably just stare and be a bit starstruck, now that I'm thinking about it. Did you manage to say hi?
Oooh I missed this post earlier, so I'm glad it got replied to. Definitely appreciate that observation. <3 And confirmation that they just pack together is so domestic and adorable!
User avatar
Ablissa
pastel persona
Posts: 1379
Joined: Thu May 05, 2016 5:49 pm
Pronouns: she/her

alittledizzy wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 7:36 pm Not to diminish anyone's examples, but there's kind of a scale difference here. "Said a racist thing and made the office environment uncomfortable" vs "Actively and knowingly used humor in a manner that encouraged the entire alt-right movement and influenced the financial landscape of the entire industry because they didn't know when to quit" are like... different scales. The more visibility you have, the more personal responsibility for your influence you should take. But that's a slightly different topic.
You're right. I keep thinking of them like they're normal people, and as such, draw comparisons to my own life. But they're not, and they do reach quite far, so I understand why people are disappointed in them. However, I wonder how many people, being in their position, would truly have the strength to speak out against someone like him and face the backlash. It's a double-edged sword, really. So many youtubers are still openly supporting him and defending him.
Katka wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 8:01 pm If deppy are anything it’s non-confrontational. They’ve never taken part in or reacted to any kind of drama and I think to them this is what this is. I’m not happy about it and it does make me question them to be honest because right now I can’t be sure what they really think. I like to believe they both realise what Felix did was terrible and that it’s not just a little slip-up but I can’t be sure because they don’t talk about this kind of thing. So right now there are two options: Either they do believe what they say about equality and stuff like that and just don’t want to get mixed up in controversy or they just say “woke” stuff because everyone’s doing it right now and their private thoughts on some things are quite different. We don’t know. This is a problem for me atm because I used to think “They wouldn’t do this harmful thing because they’re usually quite woke and educated on these subjects” but now I’m wondering if they really are and if they’re not… does it mean they would do the harmful thing?
I believe they are aware that what Felix did is wrong. They have both spoken about similar matters in the past. They may not be as aware as they should be, but surely, they must know. Although if you asked me for proof, I don't know if I would be able to provide any.
I agree with the "non-confrontational" bit though. They seem more like the type of people to quietly support something or draw attention to positive things, rather than fighting those that are bad in the world.

I don't know, this is a difficult subject and as always, I feel I have no right to judge. Personally, I would still not condemn them for not ending their friendship with Felix. I just hope they don't openly support him or go out of their way to downplay what he is doing.
User avatar
Ewok
rainbow nerd
Posts: 233
Joined: Thu Jul 27, 2017 12:32 am
Pronouns: she/her
Location: USA

alittledizzy wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 8:09 pm
Ewok wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 8:02 pm
Brack wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 7:14 pm Hi!
Long time lurker emerging. Been stalking you all since GG days. Was afraid to post anything for ages, and don't think I really want to join in the current discussion :hmmm:
But
Probably now is not a good time to let you all know I ended up stood next to deppy at a crossroad earlier today and they are v cute when they are candid.
Also because I like to feed the idb pigeons, they only had phil's galaxy backpack between them :shrug:
(I kid because ofc there isn't much you'd need for an overnight stay lol. But figured after The Spain Suitcase, might as well)

Anyway sorry for the random post (confused excitement got to me) but hi.
Welcome, Brack :platonic:

Thanks for the cute dip & pip fodder. :blackheart: The domestic image this painted in my head is exactly what I needed today. All I want is world peace and to cuddle up in a blanket with some coffee, lmao.
(Not that the felix/deppy discourse isn't important, but sometimes it's just so heavy on my heart to think about the world we live in. Boo, I'm so emo today)

I don't even know what I'd do if I spotted them out and about in a casual setting, even though in my mind that's when I'd prefer to meet them (rather than a M&G). I'd probably just stare and be a bit starstruck, now that I'm thinking about it. Did you manage to say hi?
Oooh I missed this post earlier, so I'm glad it got replied to. Definitely appreciate that observation. <3 And confirmation that they just pack together is so domestic and adorable!
I saw something lighthearted and happy, and didn't want it to get lost in the shuffle, I jumped on it :tu:

(also didn't want to possibly overstep? but I was nervous as shit when I first posted so I have lots of love for long time lurkers hehe)
»»-————𝓯𝓵𝓸𝓹𝓹𝔂 𝓭𝓲𝓷𝓰 𝓭𝓸𝓷𝓰————-««
User avatar
kuensukki
janice from the shop
Posts: 502
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2016 6:17 pm

I'm honestly really disgusted with the pic with Felix, more than I thought I'd be. The poses, the closeness to him all is giving me bad vibes. People who say they aren't doing anything bad, sorry to break the bubble but enabling someone like him by maintaining a relationship is BAD. Anyone who isn't aware of how bad Felix is look at his thread, but I don't think that's the case. People are aware of his behavior, his slurs, his community of mysoginists and racists who found a home pretending that racist slurs re considered edgy humor and should be allowed through the notion of free speech. The things Felix influences go above and beyond just slurs in videos.

My problem with dp is aligned with what Mandy said. We are disappointed, but did we expect differently. I was one of the people that was aware of the fascination they had with being felixs friend, moreso dan who spoke about him reverently, mentioning his gaming streams and videos. They obviously enjoy his company, his humor so a part of me feels like they just wouldn't leave him no matter what. It's not even the power Felix has, dp are also powerful, they have their own company and a huge amount of influence in their own way. They COULD have left the friendship, or atleast excused their attendance to a birthday of they really felt bothered or personally attacked by Felix but they don't. At the end of the day they're privileged white men that won't ever be effected so they can choose to hang out with someone like Felix and still have people defending them and saying "it's hard to leave a friend like that". Honestly, it's not. They've done it before, Chris got difficult so the relationship disappeared why wasn't that the case with Felix??

I guess supporting two people comes with the burden of disappointment and I'll loudly say this is one of those times when I feel as if dp are problematic. Them taking cutesy pictures with someone like Felix is telling their followers that it is okay to be friend and maintain a relationship with someone who has been known again and again to encourage a racist and overall dark community. That in my books is not excusable. They're adults, they are selfish, they are choosing to publicslly associate with him. Those are the facts.
Image
User avatar
coffeepenguin
rainbow nerd
Posts: 237
Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2016 5:27 pm
Pronouns: she/her
Location: France

Catallena wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 7:51 pm
coffeepenguin wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 6:08 pm Hi guys, great spooky design :skeleton: :thumb: so, uhm, many great things have happened lately (Dan’s video :love2: ), but I didn't feel like posting. In the end, as always, I couldn't stay away from a controversial topic, so now I want to weigh in on the whole Felix situation (under spoiler, because controversial opinion, but don’t crucify me yet, I'm not planning of defending Felix, ok?) :?
I am generally a bit bothered by the “deppy MUST ditch Felix” discourse, but I wasn't sure how to present my argument against it and real life just offered a great example, so here you go.

Yesterday, I went to a friend’s birthday party. She’s not racist or homophobic or anything-else-phobic, I’m pretty sure of it, I met her during my Master’s on human rights, she knows I'm gay, she’s never ever (to my knowledge) said anything offensive to any minority, she was friends with another one of our classmates who was black AND gay AND Muslim, you know, and plenty of other reasons why she’s not a Bad Person. However, her boyfriend of three years, whom she’s planning on marrying, is islamophobic and talks about it a lot (mind you, he doesn't think he is, he just thinks Islam is incompatible with respecting human rights and dignity and somehow finds this way of thinking ok).

Now, some of our mutual friends stopped socialising with my friend and her boyfriend because they find his opinions wrong and talking to him about it uncomfortable. I didn't, although I, too, completely disagree with him and do not particularly enjoy discussing the issue with him. Why? Because I don’t think it’ll accomplish anything if I just cut him from my life, I’ll just lose my friend because it’s difficult to find occasions to meet as it is, we’re both pretty busy people. Instead, I prefer to visit them when it’s someone’s birthday or for the New Year and when he starts on his favourite topic, I calmly offer my counter-arguments to what he’s saying. I honestly think this is a much better way to make the world a better and safer place than just to cut people from your life (side note: it’s all great to say “find better friends” but when you live in a foreign country and sometimes work 24/7, it’s not so easy, I literally found myself completely alone for last year’s winter holidays and I couldn't leave the country to go back to my family, if it were not for this friend, I would spend the New Year’s Eve on youtube in my pjs with a bottle of vodka. Not that it in any way relates to deppy, but I just wanted to complain and Dan and Phil have their own reasons for why it can be difficult to find friends). Now, of course, nobody among us is famous or anything, like all these youtubers, but the guy I'm talking about works as a teacher in primary school, for instance, so he has a pretty big role in shaping young minds. Do I find it dangerous? Maybe, a little bit. But what’s the alternative? Are we talking about legally banning people from jobs or the society in general because of their opinions, however bad they are? I hope not. Then, people, of course, have every right, as a private citizen, not to engage with somebody they don’t like. Me, I choose to engage because otherwise nothing will change, people you cut from your life will just become bitter and will even maybe turn to worse things. I'm not saying this is exactly what Deppy are thinking, but treating them as complete garbage just because they continue to socialize with someone like Felix, when they made it very clear they disagree with him and don’t give him any promotion (not that he needs it, I’ll grant you that), seems to me as a somewhat immature reaction and one that doesn't really help with the bringing forward progress on social issues we all care about. (My friend, btw, clearly disagrees with her boyfriend, too, and although she doesn't really publicly go into debates with him, when he starts talking about Muslims, she’s always trying to subtly shut him down or make excuses, and we've talked with her about this issue being the only thing that bothers her in an otherwise perfect guy and how she hopes he’ll change because they’re talking about it in private.)

love&peace to everyone <3 (I'm not trying to be condescending, btw, I sincerely love everyone on this forum and hope y'all are having a great day)
Here's my problem with anecdotes like this because I've thought about this a bit the past few days. This post is not only directed at you btw it's partly a draft of something generic I wrote a few days ago so it's also a bit of a mess (I tried my best to save it and form it into something coherent).

You and your racist or any other kind of -ist or -phobic friend are probably equals. Your friend does not have significant power over one of the world's biggest online platforms and the relatively small community that comes with it that is important to your career. Your friend does not silence your criticism by manipulating you with the power they have over that community and essentially forcing you to publicly apologize for not being blindly supportive (yeah yeah I don't actually have any actual proof of manipulation but what happend with Jackscepticeye's criticism still gives me the creeps) and a bad friend. Your friend is not the literal internet poster boy of the young alt-right and actively pandering to that part of his fanbase, fucking up the platform yo depend on for everyone by being one of the major causes of the aforementioned adpocalypse which is hitting minorities particularly hard.

Friends who are equals can go into legitimate discussion with each other. But the people around Felix are not his equals (no not even Marzia and someone still needs to explain to me why people keep giving her a pass and assume she will call him out when we have no proof she's at all educated about this and it not being beneficial for her to do so) and he damn well knows it because he keeps fucking up and giving out non apologies because he knows he doesn't really have peers or superiors who can make him feel consequences.

There's another layer to this. When we interact with our problematic friends we are not public people. Not to force D&P into the the roles of 24/7 role models because that's unfair, but they do have a significant influence over young people of all races, ethnicities, sexualities and genders. And by interacting with other public figures they give out a message. D&P who are generally seen as decent people despite their many privileges hanging with Felix makes it easier for other to excuse him. And in this case making the interaction public was even their choice so it's not like one can completely defend this with 'it was private!' or anything.
I understand the point you're making and I recognise that there's a big difference, dizzy has brought up a similar argument on the previous page, I agree with that one, too. However, I think that there are two important arguments here. First, maybe I give Dan too much credit, but I like to believe what people are saying until proven otherwise, so I'll be assuming he was indeed planning on talking to Felix, at least at the time of his ls. Now, I recognize that, as a white person, I am privileged, and not directly concerned, and that's why I can keep socialising with the guy I was talking about, without any particular problems for myself. And deppy, being rich white boys, are super privileged. But isn't it exactly our duty as privileged white people to educate other privileged white people when they're refuse to listen to those from minority groups who are directly concerned by the issue? IIRC it was you Catallena who made an argument that if Dan really does talk to Felix and he changes his opinions, it doesn't really mean anything, because it just shows that the only opinion that matters to Felix is one of a white person. Yeah, ok, but "use your power wisely" and all that.

Second, about being friends in private so that not to influence their "young impressionable audience", they really can't, can they? It will inevitably be shared by someone, it's not like Dan and Phil are posting photos with Felix on their instagram, it's others. Deppy could, of course, ask other people who are present there not to include them in the stuff these people share on their social media, but Deppy can't just say it like that, they have to explain themselves, and here they go having a debate not only with Felix, but also with all those other people, like PJ (why aren't we shaming PJ again? I know the last time this question was asked, people said it's not a forum about PJ, but it doesn't prevent us from bringing down Emma in the main thread). They really only have two choices, either cut ties with Felix completely or continue socializing with him when he's present at an event where they've been invited to, while maintaining what their own position is and trying to educate him. Another option, btw, is that Deppy decided to go this time precisely to, like, give it a last chance and see what he's like in person after all of this (it's not like they've spoken since last Autumn, is it?), they may very well ditch him afterwards.
plath and Katka, because of your avatars, I find it hilarious when you both post at the same time, it happened now twice in the last couple of days, it's perfect :)
Dan wants to be understood. Phil just wants to make the viewer smile and sell some backpacks (c) fancybum
onetruetrash
blobfish
Posts: 655
Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2017 3:35 am

kuensukki wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 9:03 pm I'm honestly really disgusted with the pic with Felix, more than I thought I'd be. The poses, the closeness to him all is giving me bad vibes. People who say they aren't doing anything bad, sorry to break the bubble but enabling someone like him by maintaining a relationship is BAD. Anyone who isn't aware of how bad Felix is look at his thread, but I don't think that's the case. People are aware of his behavior, his slurs, his community of mysoginists and racists who found a home pretending that racist slurs re considered edgy humor and should be allowed through the notion of free speech. The things Felix influences go above and beyond just slurs in videos.

My problem with dp is aligned with what Mandy said. We are disappointed, but did we expect differently. I was one of the people that was aware of the fascination they had with being felixs friend, moreso dan who spoke about him reverently, mentioning his gaming streams and videos. They obviously enjoy his company, his humor so a part of me feels like they just wouldn't leave him no matter what. It's not even the power Felix has, dp are also powerful, they have their own company and a huge amount of influence in their own way. They COULD have left the friendship, or atleast excused their attendance to a birthday of they really felt bothered or personally attacked by Felix but they don't. At the end of the day they're privileged white men that won't ever be effected so they can choose to hang out with someone like Felix and still have people defending them and saying "it's hard to leave a friend like that". Honestly, it's not. They've done it before, Chris got difficult so the relationship disappeared why wasn't that the case with Felix??

I guess supporting two people comes with the burden of disappointment and I'll loudly say this is one of those times when I feel as if dp are problematic. Them taking cutesy pictures with someone like Felix is telling their followers that it is okay to be friend and maintain a relationship with someone who has been known again and again to encourage a racist and overall dark community. That in my books is not excusable. They're adults, they are selfish, they are choosing to publicslly associate with him. Those are the facts.
This. People are overestimating the power Felix has and underestimating the power Dan and Phil have. Dan and Phil are the most popular YouTube duo, hell, they even have a forum dedicated to them that we're all on right now.

And "it's hard to leave a friend" is total bullshit. I'm sorry, but Dan and Phil have dropped friends left and right, friends that they were even closer to than Felix for that matter. Dropping Felix would not be that difficult for them. And if they were afraid of starting drama, they could just follow him and Twitter and talk to him at events and stuff and other things where they did not have to publicly associate with him.
Brack
tol bean
Posts: 14
Joined: Tue Apr 26, 2016 4:26 am
Pronouns: she/her
Location: London

Ewok wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 8:02 pm
Brack wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 7:14 pm Hi!
Long time lurker emerging. Been stalking you all since GG days. Was afraid to post anything for ages, and don't think I really want to join in the current discussion :hmmm:
But
Probably now is not a good time to let you all know I ended up stood next to deppy at a crossroad earlier today and they are v cute when they are candid.
Also because I like to feed the idb pigeons, they only had phil's galaxy backpack between them :shrug:
(I kid because ofc there isn't much you'd need for an overnight stay lol. But figured after The Spain Suitcase, might as well)

Anyway sorry for the random post (confused excitement got to me) but hi.
Welcome, Brack :platonic:

Thanks for the cute dip & pip fodder. :blackheart: The domestic image this painted in my head is exactly what I needed today. All I want is world peace and to cuddle up in a blanket with some coffee, lmao.
(Not that the felix/deppy discourse isn't important, but sometimes it's just so heavy on my heart to think about the world we live in. Boo, I'm so emo today)

I don't even know what I'd do if I spotted them out and about in a casual setting, even though in my mind that's when I'd prefer to meet them (rather than a M&G). I'd probably just stare and be a bit starstruck, now that I'm thinking about it. Did you manage to say hi?
Thank you :platonic:!

(Of course the current discussion is important, but I guess it's nice to soften the tone just a little bit with something else.)

I, too, have always wondered what I'd do if I bumped into them somewhere...turns out that even stood right beside them and with every opportunity to say hi, I'd do nothing :lol: Unfortunately my level of social anxiety does not allow for action, even if it is D&P :lol:


Also, don't know if it's been seen before but Dan's jacket is quite...interesting at the back. Think neoprene...or suede skirt :eh:
User avatar
SquishPhan
capita£ester
Posts: 2502
Joined: Sun Mar 27, 2016 11:18 pm
Pronouns: she/her
Location: The Netherlands

I'd be down for this. ;)
User avatar
liola
rankussy
Posts: 1679
Joined: Fri Jul 14, 2017 3:09 pm
Pronouns: she/her
Location: Italy

Brack wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 9:42 pm
Ewok wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 8:02 pm
Brack wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 7:14 pm Hi!
Long time lurker emerging. Been stalking you all since GG days. Was afraid to post anything for ages, and don't think I really want to join in the current discussion :hmmm:
But
Probably now is not a good time to let you all know I ended up stood next to deppy at a crossroad earlier today and they are v cute when they are candid.
Also because I like to feed the idb pigeons, they only had phil's galaxy backpack between them :shrug:
(I kid because ofc there isn't much you'd need for an overnight stay lol. But figured after The Spain Suitcase, might as well)

Anyway sorry for the random post (confused excitement got to me) but hi.
Welcome, Brack :platonic:

Thanks for the cute dip & pip fodder. :blackheart: The domestic image this painted in my head is exactly what I needed today. All I want is world peace and to cuddle up in a blanket with some coffee, lmao.
(Not that the felix/deppy discourse isn't important, but sometimes it's just so heavy on my heart to think about the world we live in. Boo, I'm so emo today)

I don't even know what I'd do if I spotted them out and about in a casual setting, even though in my mind that's when I'd prefer to meet them (rather than a M&G). I'd probably just stare and be a bit starstruck, now that I'm thinking about it. Did you manage to say hi?
Thank you :platonic:!

(Of course the current discussion is important, but I guess it's nice to soften the tone just a little bit with something else.)

I, too, have always wondered what I'd do if I bumped into them somewhere...turns out that even stood right beside them and with every opportunity to say hi, I'd do nothing :lol: Unfortunately my level of social anxiety does not allow for action, even if it is D&P :lol:


Also, don't know if it's been seen before but Dan's jacket is quite...interesting at the back. Think neoprene...or suede skirt :eh:
Oooh I'd love to hear more about how cute candid deppy are if you wanna elaborate <3

I've already said enough about the current discussion and it's a bit too negative for my shit mental health right now so I'm gonna step away :shrug:
Will probably never be over the BONCAS and the beauty of Phil Lester.

Official Moving Hill Mayor
jesuisunèléve
phabergé
Posts: 279
Joined: Sat Sep 24, 2016 3:34 am
Location: Pacific Northwest

onetruetrash wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 9:20 pm
kuensukki wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 9:03 pm I'm honestly really disgusted with the pic with Felix, more than I thought I'd be. The poses, the closeness to him all is giving me bad vibes. People who say they aren't doing anything bad, sorry to break the bubble but enabling someone like him by maintaining a relationship is BAD. Anyone who isn't aware of how bad Felix is look at his thread, but I don't think that's the case. People are aware of his behavior, his slurs, his community of mysoginists and racists who found a home pretending that racist slurs re considered edgy humor and should be allowed through the notion of free speech. The things Felix influences go above and beyond just slurs in videos.

My problem with dp is aligned with what Mandy said. We are disappointed, but did we expect differently. I was one of the people that was aware of the fascination they had with being felixs friend, moreso dan who spoke about him reverently, mentioning his gaming streams and videos. They obviously enjoy his company, his humor so a part of me feels like they just wouldn't leave him no matter what. It's not even the power Felix has, dp are also powerful, they have their own company and a huge amount of influence in their own way. They COULD have left the friendship, or atleast excused their attendance to a birthday of they really felt bothered or personally attacked by Felix but they don't. At the end of the day they're privileged white men that won't ever be effected so they can choose to hang out with someone like Felix and still have people defending them and saying "it's hard to leave a friend like that". Honestly, it's not. They've done it before, Chris got difficult so the relationship disappeared why wasn't that the case with Felix??

I guess supporting two people comes with the burden of disappointment and I'll loudly say this is one of those times when I feel as if dp are problematic. Them taking cutesy pictures with someone like Felix is telling their followers that it is okay to be friend and maintain a relationship with someone who has been known again and again to encourage a racist and overall dark community. That in my books is not excusable. They're adults, they are selfish, they are choosing to publicslly associate with him. Those are the facts.
This. People are overestimating the power Felix has and underestimating the power Dan and Phil have. Dan and Phil are the most popular YouTube duo, hell, they even have a forum dedicated to them that we're all on right now.

And "it's hard to leave a friend" is total bullshit. I'm sorry, but Dan and Phil have dropped friends left and right, friends that they were even closer to than Felix for that matter. Dropping Felix would not be that difficult for them. And if they were afraid of starting drama, they could just follow him and Twitter and talk to him at events and stuff and other things where they did not have to publicly associate with him.
Not a new poster, just haven't logged on for a bit and totally forgot what my user name was.

Agree with the above. :respekt2: It could be said in D&P's defense that they are there for Mariza's birthday, not for Felix. It's a stretch but I am sure it can be a valid argument.

With that out of the way, I am absolutely dismayed on the forgiveness going on for saying racial slurs. It's not OK, it's not something that can be passed off with the wave of the hand and "Oh, that person is just problematic", or "It was a mistake." If someone says the n-word, it shows me what's in their hearts. Why would they say it? It's not a commonly used word like "coffee" or even "damn".

If we are as mortified of this word as we say we are, we would be equally as mortified when someone speaks it, and we would not be explaining away why it's OK to say it if a person apologizes. You see, apologies don't work after the fact because the word is now out there, in the world, existing. Again. ;ghost; ;ghost; ;ghost; :bat: :pumpkinphil: :vampire:
User avatar
alittledizzy
actual demon phannie
actual demon phannie
Posts: 7101
Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 3:09 pm
Pronouns: she/her

lovelyhandfood wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 10:17 pmNot a new poster, just haven't logged on for a bit and totally forgot what my user name was.
Hi! We actually don't allow multiple accounts per user, but if you send me a PM we can sort out what your old account was. :)
User avatar
dancy
procrastinator
Posts: 320
Joined: Sun Oct 15, 2017 1:45 pm

Found this on Marzia's blog

Image

As for the ongoing conversation, I too am quite disappointed about the fact that D&P are still associating with Felix. It has truly made me feel uncomfortable and it still does but I'm trying to remind myself that this was Marzia's birthday party. They were invited by her, just like in the previous two years. They came for her, not for Felix and while Marzia is his girlfriend, she's also her own person.

Dan has mentioned before that he and Phil love her and that they have "nerdy conversations" with her about horror movies so I'd say they're closer to her than they're to Felix. I'm not completely okay with what's happened but I don't think they're bad people for attending a friendly gathering and hanging out with that meatball once a year.
User avatar
alch
ar·tic·u·late
Posts: 413
Joined: Wed Aug 30, 2017 9:00 pm
Pronouns: she/her
Location: USA

lovelyhandfood wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 10:17 pm
With that out of the way, I am absolutely dismayed on the forgiveness going on for saying racial slurs. It's not OK, it's not something that can be passed off with the wave of the hand and "Oh, that person is just problematic", or "It was a mistake." If someone says the n-word, it shows me what's in their hearts. Why would they say it? It's not a commonly used word like "coffee" or even "damn".
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think anyone was pardoning Felix for saying that word. It was an awful thing to do, he shouldn't have it in his vocabulary, he's definitely racist. The question was more whether or not deppy should drop him as a friend for saying the word or not.
User avatar
captainspacecoat
stress mushroom
Posts: 605
Joined: Sun Sep 11, 2016 2:31 am
Pronouns: she/her
Location: Australia

Nah, there's no way they were there just for Marzia - Felix's birthday is the 24th of October so I'm sure it was partly for him as well, regardless of what they said.

That photo definitely makes me uncomfortable. I've been very vocal about my hatred for Felix on IDB since January this year, and I honestly find it disgusting that anyone can excuse his behaviour at this point. And that's what Dan and Phil (and PJ and Sophie) are doing by hanging out with him. Seeing Dan stood directly next to him is just gross honestly, and there's nothing forcing them to be there, they won't lose out on anything or suffer any consequences by dropping him or publicly condemning him. They have a choice to make between a) implicitly condoning a man who has fuelled the growing 'alt-right' movement and who has gained notoriety through his anti-semitic jokes, misogyny and frequent use of the n-word, or b) siding with people of colour and making it clear that they do not support Felix or his views in any way. They chose the former, and that really fucking sucks.

Do I think Dan and Phil are explicitly racist? No. I, perhaps naively, truly don't believe they use racist slurs in their personal lives. I believe they are genuinely politically aligned to the left, and for the most part their (admittedly vague) support for certain causes is genuine. But by hanging out with Felix they do at the very least make clear their privilege as white men, and their ability to compartmentalise and sideline issues that are of the utmost importance to some people as something that isn't a deal breaker for them. As white men, Dan and Phil are not directly harmed by the racist/misogynistic things Felix says and does, and so they were able to put those things aside and enjoy a fun night with their friends (although, I'm secretly glad Emma Blackery was there to put a damper on that, karma's a bitch).

I personally can't relate, and so I'm judging them really hard right now. I would never remain friends with someone who shared Felix's views, and I recognise that it may be easier said than done but I think they should just suck it up and drop his ass, no matter the potential consequence.

Does this mean I'm unstanning Dan and Phil? No. I'm in too deep at this point (does that make me hypocritical given what I just said? I truly don't know, maybe it does). Whether it's healthy or not, Dan and Phil remain an essential form of escapism for me and I don't want to lose that. Also, this wasn't a surprise. We knew they were hanging out with Felix, I think it was just the photo that really put it into perspective for me. I'm sure after some time has passed I'll be able to step back a bit and hopefully feel a bit better about the situation, but right now I'm just pretty disappointed. Again, I want to reiterate that I don't think Dan and Phil are horrible people with no redeeming qualities for this, just that I expected better and I hope as a fandom we can hold them to account for associating with somebody like Felix.
onetruetrash
blobfish
Posts: 655
Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2017 3:35 am

Am I the only one who feels like this whole Felix conversation is going nowhere fast?
User avatar
alittledizzy
actual demon phannie
actual demon phannie
Posts: 7101
Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 3:09 pm
Pronouns: she/her

onetruetrash wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 11:16 pm Am I the only one who feels like this whole Felix conversation is going nowhere fast?
Out of curiosity, where do you expect it to go? I feel like fans are processing and talking it out amongst themselves, which is about all we can do since this is not a situation in which we have any control besides to express our approval or disapproval. The action is really in Dan and Phil's hands.
jesuisunèléve
phabergé
Posts: 279
Joined: Sat Sep 24, 2016 3:34 am
Location: Pacific Northwest

alch wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 10:55 pm
lovelyhandfood wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 10:17 pm
With that out of the way, I am absolutely dismayed on the forgiveness going on for saying racial slurs. It's not OK, it's not something that can be passed off with the wave of the hand and "Oh, that person is just problematic", or "It was a mistake." If someone says the n-word, it shows me what's in their hearts. Why would they say it? It's not a commonly used word like "coffee" or even "damn".
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think anyone was pardoning Felix for saying that word. It was an awful thing to do, he shouldn't have it in his vocabulary, he's definitely racist. The question was more whether or not deppy should drop him as a friend for saying the word or not.
I didn't say anyone was. My statement was in general, especially for "Celebrities" who drop the n word "by accident" who "didn't mean to say it" or they "said it so long ago." Felix isn't the only YT'er with problematic language, but there are some who think an apology wipes the slate clean.

As for Dip and Dot, I don't understand their behavior because as its been said upthread, they have "dumped" people before. So, the question is, why not Felix? Because he's the largest YTer? We don't know, but that picture is creating questions that should be answered.
onetruetrash
blobfish
Posts: 655
Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2017 3:35 am

alittledizzy wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 11:26 pm
onetruetrash wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 11:16 pm Am I the only one who feels like this whole Felix conversation is going nowhere fast?
Out of curiosity, where do you expect it to go? I feel like fans are processing and talking it out amongst themselves, which is about all we can do since this is not a situation in which we have any control besides to express our approval or disapproval. The actual is really in Dan and Phil's hands.
Yeah, I just feel like everything that there is to be said has been said.
User avatar
kuensukki
janice from the shop
Posts: 502
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2016 6:17 pm

onetruetrash wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 9:20 pm
kuensukki wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 9:03 pm I'm honestly really disgusted with the pic with Felix, more than I thought I'd be. The poses, the closeness to him all is giving me bad vibes. People who say they aren't doing anything bad, sorry to break the bubble but enabling someone like him by maintaining a relationship is BAD. Anyone who isn't aware of how bad Felix is look at his thread, but I don't think that's the case. People are aware of his behavior, his slurs, his community of mysoginists and racists who found a home pretending that racist slurs re considered edgy humor and should be allowed through the notion of free speech. The things Felix influences go above and beyond just slurs in videos.

My problem with dp is aligned with what Mandy said. We are disappointed, but did we expect differently. I was one of the people that was aware of the fascination they had with being felixs friend, moreso dan who spoke about him reverently, mentioning his gaming streams and videos. They obviously enjoy his company, his humor so a part of me feels like they just wouldn't leave him no matter what. It's not even the power Felix has, dp are also powerful, they have their own company and a huge amount of influence in their own way. They COULD have left the friendship, or atleast excused their attendance to a birthday of they really felt bothered or personally attacked by Felix but they don't. At the end of the day they're privileged white men that won't ever be effected so they can choose to hang out with someone like Felix and still have people defending them and saying "it's hard to leave a friend like that". Honestly, it's not. They've done it before, Chris got difficult so the relationship disappeared why wasn't that the case with Felix??

I guess supporting two people comes with the burden of disappointment and I'll loudly say this is one of those times when I feel as if dp are problematic. Them taking cutesy pictures with someone like Felix is telling their followers that it is okay to be friend and maintain a relationship with someone who has been known again and again to encourage a racist and overall dark community. That in my books is not excusable. They're adults, they are selfish, they are choosing to publicslly associate with him. Those are the facts.
This. People are overestimating the power Felix has and underestimating the power Dan and Phil have. Dan and Phil are the most popular YouTube duo, hell, they even have a forum dedicated to them that we're all on right now.

And "it's hard to leave a friend" is total bullshit. I'm sorry, but Dan and Phil have dropped friends left and right, friends that they were even closer to than Felix for that matter. Dropping Felix would not be that difficult for them. And if they were afraid of starting drama, they could just follow him and Twitter and talk to him at events and stuff and other things where they did not have to publicly associate with him.
Yessss!! There's this whole argument that DP dropping Felix would be a bad business move of affect their brand but dp and Felix run in two different social circles completely. Their fanbases are also separate and completely strong on their own so honestly it wouldn't hurt them to publically or even privately cut ties. I'm just very torn because if it was anyone else I would be gone but because dp as individuals seem like good people it's hard to leave them. They themselves are entertaining even tho sometimes I feel as if I think they're much greater than they actually are (damn stan culture). It's not something I'd leave for but I also want to be honest to myself that they are doing nothing to denounce these kind of men and instead are standing next to them publically.
Image
User avatar
rizzo
unduly facetious
unduly facetious
Posts: 1792
Joined: Tue Mar 29, 2016 3:18 am

dancy wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 10:52 pm Found this on Marzia's blog
Image
I'm sorry, but am I the only one who finds this hilarious and shameless of D&P?

Last year they give her a couple of those milk carton toys they got a free box of. This year, they gave her their own game... These 2 give roughly zero fucks when it comes to giving Marzia a thoughtful gift. Incredible. :lol:
Locked