Good questions, thanks for tackling the realistic details. For proofreading, I think a beta could just copy and paste into into a word document and edit from there. Though it would be easy if we could also just have a text file in addition to a formatted page, if the writer chooses to do that.districthirteen wrote:Just wondering, so far people have been posting up completed pages as pdf files (which look totally great and I'm enjoying very very much) but eventually someone would have to recreate them/have access to the raw file to be able to do formatting/fix typos/beta stuff right? Just wondering how would things best be done?
And if we are going to compile things on InDesign, would we recreate pages from scratch or like, take screenshots of the existing pages and fit it in? To me it's like, the original creators must have put a lot of thought and effort into the layouts, and I wouldn't want to waste their effort, but ... everyone uses different platforms and Idk how we should best standardise things.
Sorry to bring stressful (and realistic) ideas into a fun project! But I would really like to see a (semi-)professional looking end product, hence all these icky questions.
Also, I've done some school magazines on InDesign before so I can somewhat navigate my way around there and I'm pretty good at spotting typos so I can offer my limited services if needed? Though I think there's no shortage of betas at the moment, but just putting it out there!
As for adhering to an original design, I was thinking for the pages people have already both written and formatted, someone could easily just recreate it in whatever program we decide to go with. Like, keep the color combinations, fonts, and whatever else the person really wanted in there and use their pdf/file/whatever as a skeleton, which would take some of the pressure of designing a layout from scratch off the designer. If there are any pictures included, we'd just need to message the original creator for the original image.
kooshka, you raise an excellent point. I, for one, know how to use photoshop but not indesign (I also think I only have a trial version of it?). when you say:
does that mean we can still use photoshop to put this together, so long as we all use the same page dimensions and font sizes, etc?but then ground-set rules for page dimensions, font sizes etc play a much bigger role since they can't be scaled.