Dan's mom was at the final UK showing of TATINOF cheering them on, and Dan said in a video that he asked his mom about leaving uni and she said it was all right to do so. Dan is VERY private about his parents and his brother, but apparently its appropriate to spend Christmas with your family. Phil is a mommy's boy (so I have been told) so he couldn't spend time away from his family.MoonPride wrote:Regarding Christmas I really think the only reason Dan goes home and not home with Phil is because of his Grandma. I also really get the feeling Dan's parents resent Phil and feel like he is the reason Dan gave up on uni. This is just my assumption and to save any bad atmosphere it's easier to spend Christmas apart.
Why is anyone thinking #phandivorce is a thing? They are going to be living together until they are old and grey.
Dan & Phil Part 33: #JustBroThings
-
- phabergé
- Posts: 279
- Joined: Sat Sep 24, 2016 3:34 am
- Location: Pacific Northwest
Last edited by jesuisunèléve on Mon Dec 12, 2016 9:25 am, edited 1 time in total.
It's just what I think, I also think Dan's parents are not very comfortable with Dan's sexuality and I really think the way he acted in 2012 was partly due to them not accepting that he loved Phil esp as his previous relationship was with a girl for 3 years.jesuisunèléve wrote:I never even thought of that. Wow...that's not cool, especially since Phil's parents have taken to Dan.MoonPride wrote:Regarding Christmas I really think the only reason Dan goes home and not home with Phil is because of his Grandma. I also really get the feeling Dan's parents resent Phil and feel like he is the reason Dan gave up on uni. This is just my assumption and to save any bad atmosphere it's easier to spend Christmas apart.
Why is anyone thinking #phandivorce is a thing? They are going to be living together until they are old and grey.
I wouldn't want to take my partner home for Christmas knowing it would just cause drama. It be easier to just do our own thing and celebrate together just before the Christmas season.
- papierklemmen
- flower crown
- Posts: 732
- Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2016 11:04 am
mm well i'm still not convinced, but it's ok. he specifically said he spent "this year" with dan, and i'm sure he has no illusions regarding his individual channel's "content" in 2016, so it was basically him sharing the award with his tatinof partner. (also, imagine the shitstorm from the phandom if he didn't share this award with dan ). but i agree that your interpretation is as plausible, especially since their behavior has been quite different since then.jesuisunèléve wrote:Read what you just wrote, you answered your own questionpapierklemmen wrote:sorry for changing the subject, i wasn't here during the boncas discussion, can you explain how he "threw the closet door open for them"? is it because he asked dan to come up on stage? i thought it was only fair since they worked as a duo 24/7, it's not really indicative of a non-platonic relationship.jesuisunèléve wrote: Now? Well, Phil threw the closet door open for them at the Boncas and it seems like we are on a whole new trajectory with Deppy. It's refreshing AF.
Phil's award was Creator of the Year. No Dan, not Dan and Phil, but Phil. That award belongs to no one else but him. He didn't have to share, especially since there was really nothing to share, but he decided to show the world that even though he won that award as a sole creator, he chose to share it with the person who has been by his side for what, 7 years? So there is no "fair", as you say, about it. That was Phil's award, he didn't have to bring Dan up with him.
"They worked as a duo 24/7": they have separate channels, so on the surface they do not. Phil has his own content and so does Dan. It could be they ask for advice from one another, but there is a big difference between content between the two channels.
Does that help?
-
- phabergé
- Posts: 279
- Joined: Sat Sep 24, 2016 3:34 am
- Location: Pacific Northwest
papierklemmen wrote:mm well i'm still not convinced, but it's ok. he specifically said he spent "this year" with dan, and i'm sure he has no illusions regarding his individual channel's "content" in 2016, so it was basically him sharing the award with his tatinof partner. (also, imagine the shitstorm from the phandom if he didn't share this award with dan ). but i agree that your interpretation is as plausible, especially since their behavior has been quite different since then.jesuisunèléve wrote:Read what you just wrote, you answered your own questionpapierklemmen wrote:sorry for changing the subject, i wasn't here during the boncas discussion, can you explain how he "threw the closet door open for them"? is it because he asked dan to come up on stage? i thought it was only fair since they worked as a duo 24/7, it's not really indicative of a non-platonic relationship.jesuisunèléve wrote: Now? Well, Phil threw the closet door open for them at the Boncas and it seems like we are on a whole new trajectory with Deppy. It's refreshing AF.
Phil's award was Creator of the Year. No Dan, not Dan and Phil, but Phil. That award belongs to no one else but him. He didn't have to share, especially since there was really nothing to share, but he decided to show the world that even though he won that award as a sole creator, he chose to share it with the person who has been by his side for what, 7 years? So there is no "fair", as you say, about it. That was Phil's award, he didn't have to bring Dan up with him.
"They worked as a duo 24/7": they have separate channels, so on the surface they do not. Phil has his own content and so does Dan. It could be they ask for advice from one another, but there is a big difference between content between the two channels.
Does that help?
I don't think the Phandom would have lost their mind if Phil took the award on his own, to be honest. Everyone knows Phil has been on the YT forever with little to no credit, and this award was huge for him, which is why everyone held their breath when he said he's spent 2016 with another person and invited Dan up on stage with him (Dan waddling up to the stage was perfect lol).
Also, the award wasn't for TATINOF, it was for Creator of the Year. Another reason why Phil didn't have to share with Dan.
And you pointed out something I am grateful you noticed: that since Boncas things have changed between them. Who knows what it is, maybe they are more comfortable? Maybe its rebranding to simply have them as a duo becuase that's how everyone else sees them? Regardless, things HAVE changed, and we're all having a great time with it.
I don't believe they are platonic, nor do I expect a verbal outing from them either. The standard YT formula is to come out, ride the wave of fame, then fizzle out. We already know Deppy do not do what everyone else does (I mean, who the hell else on the YT writes a book and does a stage show to back it up??) so I don't plan on them to follow that route. Besides, there is more meaning to them acknowledging their relationship without using words.
But what about his Dad? We really know nothing about him.jesuisunèléve wrote:Dan's mom was at the final UK showing of TATINOF cheering them on, and Dan said in a video that he asked his mom about leaving uni and she said it was all right to do so. Dan is VERY private about his parents and his brother, but apparently its appropriate to spend Christmas with your family. Phil is a mommy's boy (so I have been told) so he couldn't spend time away from his family.MoonPride wrote:Regarding Christmas I really think the only reason Dan goes home and not home with Phil is because of his Grandma. I also really get the feeling Dan's parents resent Phil and feel like he is the reason Dan gave up on uni. This is just my assumption and to save any bad atmosphere it's easier to spend Christmas apart.
Why is anyone thinking #phandivorce is a thing? They are going to be living together until they are old and grey.
- mermaid blood
- Moderator Emeritus
- Posts: 529
- Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 6:48 pm
- Pronouns: she/her
I actually feel like Dan has spoken more about his father than his mother. in terms of personality and random anecdotes, anyway.
art in avatar by lily
- mermaid blood
- Moderator Emeritus
- Posts: 529
- Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 6:48 pm
- Pronouns: she/her
i feel like mostly the radioshow? and then some old vyous, livenows, and i guess that one main channel (audience participation) was pretty insightful. i feel like i know nothing about his mother, other than she went on a rollercoaster with him when he was a kid even though she's scared of them so he wouldn't have to be alone. (love that one).MoonPride wrote:I'd love to know where I can find them.mermaid blood wrote:I actually feel like Dan has spoken more about his father than his mother. in terms of personality and random anecdotes, anyway.
edit: i'm not the person to bring up links, i wish i was. probably oq has a lot?
his dad is into music and he used to listen to new albums in the car with him, he loves F1 racing, used to work as a special effects tech, dan visited him onset at Pinewood Studios once, he filled Dan's room with fake snow to surprise him on christmas day and it made him cry, he took them diving and that's when he and Dan nearly got killed by the spear fisher, he lived in Vietnam with his little brother for a while because their father was in the military and there was dog in the rice paddy that they thought was haunted, he yelled at dan for bleeding on the carpet that one time, he hid chocolate from their family dog but she got on top of their wardrobe or something and ate it anyway, that's just what i can remember off the top of my head.
edit 2: and he used to smoke, right? cigars? or cigar smell makes Dan think of his dad.
Last edited by mermaid blood on Mon Dec 12, 2016 10:42 am, edited 2 times in total.
art in avatar by lily
-
- tol bean
- Posts: 10
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 7:20 pm
[offtopic]Not super helpful here, but[/offtopic]jesuisunèléve wrote:Dan's mom was at the final UK showing of TATINOF cheering them on, and Dan said in a video that he asked his mom about leaving uni and she said it was all right to do so. Dan is VERY private about his parents and his brother, but apparently its appropriate to spend Christmas with your family. Phil is a mommy's boy (so I have been told) so he couldn't spend time away from his family.MoonPride wrote:Regarding Christmas I really think the only reason Dan goes home and not home with Phil is because of his Grandma. I also really get the feeling Dan's parents resent Phil and feel like he is the reason Dan gave up on uni. This is just my assumption and to save any bad atmosphere it's easier to spend Christmas apart.
I've always wondered about his dad as well, because while with his mom he at least mentions a bit, his father is almost ignored. I re-watched Audience Participation Fear a bit ago and was surprised that he actually mentions his parents. He describes how his father also has an "audience participation fear" (aka social anxiety from what I'm picking up). That doesn't really help all too much with this conversation unless someone can read more into this than I can.
Coming from my experiences, both having social anxiety and a parent having it, mixed with us not really seeing each other when I was younger, and since we went so long without creating a close/traditional parent-child bond we still don't have a close relationship. He worked a lot when I was young, and once I was a teen it's a bit too late (for most people, not all) to make up for the years of lost times. Since neither of us put ourselves out there to create connections we just aren't close and that's not really going to change.
It seems like that's very similar to Dan (from what I limited-ly know and speculate)--a parent who works a lot, a lack of ambition to create and maintain most relationships, and the other party having the same social anxiety as he does. From what I speculate, it doesn't seem like there's any one thing causeing a divide between each other, it just seems he doesn't have or wants to create a closer relationship with his parents, and because of that they don't understand each other or their choices very well, which makes it hard to be close to each other.
(he also jokes "we should hang out more" when talking about his mom, which I found interesting, and totally something I would jokingly say about my estranged parents).
If this is about my joke a bit ago, I don't actually believe in #phandivorce, I'm too for that. It's just me finding it adorable how they share almost all their stuff combined with how crazy it seems that anyone (including at times myself) used to think they would move away from each otherMoonPride wrote:Why is anyone thinking #phandivorce is a thing? They are going to be living together until they are old and grey.
Last edited by poweredbywords on Mon Dec 12, 2016 10:48 am, edited 4 times in total.
- mermaid blood
- Moderator Emeritus
- Posts: 529
- Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 6:48 pm
- Pronouns: she/her
^ he used to mention his parents more frequently, and basically in a neutral tone, until i'd say 2013 or 2014.
even on the radioshow up until the end he was still talking about them, though. he told the story about the neighbours renovating in 2015 and his mum telling him the little girls from next door could see straight into his parent's bedroom now.
edit: i would agree about it seeming his dad may have some similar traits. as a child of a very similar parent i can relate to that sometimes making certain things difficult.
even on the radioshow up until the end he was still talking about them, though. he told the story about the neighbours renovating in 2015 and his mum telling him the little girls from next door could see straight into his parent's bedroom now.
edit: i would agree about it seeming his dad may have some similar traits. as a child of a very similar parent i can relate to that sometimes making certain things difficult.
art in avatar by lily
Hello everyone! I'm not internet savvy, so sorry for not posting a link but I specifically remember him talking extensively about his dad on a halloween themed liveshow (I think in 2012). If I remember correctley it's the one where Phil tries to scare him standing behind a door but Dan sees him.
Please don't mind any errors, I'm not a native speaker.
Please don't mind any errors, I'm not a native speaker.
- flarequake
- not an airport stalker
- Posts: 2680
- Joined: Tue Mar 29, 2016 8:55 pm
- Pronouns: She/her
- Location: London, UK
The storm seems to have passed, but only just, I nodded along to fancybum's post, I thought there were a lot of good points about how something just meant as a lighthearted joke can have meaning and not everyone has to be happy about it. Reductive is a good word for it and it's jarring against everyone loving how refreshingly relaxed the guys have been lately.
I also don't think we have to just keep to forum rules and not question when something within them still seems off or not discuss social issues, we got pages out of something Dan joked about in a live show a few months ago because we're a discussion forum. Ignoring it is an option ofc, but that shouldn't cover everything, saying nothing lets things continue and not everything should. We're a big and varied community, we're not always going to agree and we should be able to discuss things whether we do or not.
I get the argument for throwing the doors open at the Boncas, but I didn't see it that way, it felt just as reasonable for colleagues who've spent the year touring a two-man show and collabing on nearly everything.
That Reddit post is funny, trust Dan to be referencing something almost privately as most of the phandom wouldn't have seen it.
Interesting anecdotes about Dan's parents too. I haven't seen most of the old live shows or radio shows so hadn't realised he'd said more about them than in his videos.
I also don't think we have to just keep to forum rules and not question when something within them still seems off or not discuss social issues, we got pages out of something Dan joked about in a live show a few months ago because we're a discussion forum. Ignoring it is an option ofc, but that shouldn't cover everything, saying nothing lets things continue and not everything should. We're a big and varied community, we're not always going to agree and we should be able to discuss things whether we do or not.
I get the argument for throwing the doors open at the Boncas, but I didn't see it that way, it felt just as reasonable for colleagues who've spent the year touring a two-man show and collabing on nearly everything.
That Reddit post is funny, trust Dan to be referencing something almost privately as most of the phandom wouldn't have seen it.
Interesting anecdotes about Dan's parents too. I haven't seen most of the old live shows or radio shows so hadn't realised he'd said more about them than in his videos.
My bingo senses/radar were tingling this morning. Guess I know why now!
Vid last night was cute, butI think I'm somewhat immune to H.E.H. these days, so I had much more of a reaction to "feel my heartbeat" the other day.
Also. - Comet is so named because back before Rudolph came along and stole all the glory, Comet and Cupid had to lead the sleigh, and one night he got smacked in the face by a shooting star Santa thought was a nav. light. So said my Grandad anyway, and he knew EVERYTHING!
Vid last night was cute, butI think I'm somewhat immune to H.E.H. these days, so I had much more of a reaction to "feel my heartbeat" the other day.
Also. - Comet is so named because back before Rudolph came along and stole all the glory, Comet and Cupid had to lead the sleigh, and one night he got smacked in the face by a shooting star Santa thought was a nav. light. So said my Grandad anyway, and he knew EVERYTHING!
IckleMissMayhem's evil fic writing alter ego. :twisted:
- bluebox-away
- woodland creature
- Posts: 588
- Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 11:28 pm
- Pronouns: she/her
- Location: London, England
I'm a couple pages behind, so not much to contribute as of right now apart from Martyn posted a cute instagram with Phil and Kath with the caption "Perfectly normal family". Also it's geotagged as York, so the wedding is there not IoM
06/04/2016 - I found The Weakest Link
Gif credit: IckleMissMayhem
Also just because his parents may be supportive of his career or he had some good memories growing up it doesn't mean they approve of his sexuality or even Phil. I know when I fell pregnant at 22 with a man my parents hated, my mum tried to be supportive but my Dad was so angry he did not speak to me properly until my Daughter was nearly 2 years old. He's fine now but it took him a long time to accept my decisions. During that time it was a horrible atmosphere to be around. So if they do have a problem with their son being in a relationship with an other man I can understand why Dan would not want Phil to be around any negativity esp over Christmas. Like I said this is just my opinion and we will never really know the truth.
-
- morning quiff
- Posts: 466
- Joined: Tue Aug 30, 2016 6:47 pm
- Pronouns: she/her
- Location: post-baking universe
I actually really like how Kath and Martyn/Cornelia are all universally loved and cherished within the fandom It would be terrifying exposing your family and not knowing the outcome of it, but I'm happy that everyone is treated well and for the most part, respectfully (I mean that as in people trying to get answers out of Martyn/Cornelia or stuff like that)
Phil has such a wonderful family and it really shows how strong of a foundation he's had to be such a nice human being. I wouldn't even know what to do if I was in his shoes- my family is the polar opposite of his.
He's so adorable, even when he's nearing 30 he has such a childlike energy to him that's contagious, and I don't mean adorable in the condescending way, I mean that he's so himself in that way, even if he restricts himself in AmazingPhil a bit.
tl;dr Phil should be Willy Wonka and I will fite anyone who disagrees
Phil has such a wonderful family and it really shows how strong of a foundation he's had to be such a nice human being. I wouldn't even know what to do if I was in his shoes- my family is the polar opposite of his.
He's so adorable, even when he's nearing 30 he has such a childlike energy to him that's contagious, and I don't mean adorable in the condescending way, I mean that he's so himself in that way, even if he restricts himself in AmazingPhil a bit.
tl;dr Phil should be Willy Wonka and I will fite anyone who disagrees
^^^^^melon lord wrote:I actually really like how Kath and Martyn/Cornelia are all universally loved and cherished within the fandom It would be terrifying exposing your family and not knowing the outcome of it, but I'm happy that everyone is treated well and for the most part, respectfully (I mean that as in people trying to get answers out of Martyn/Cornelia or stuff like that)
Phil has such a wonderful family and it really shows how strong of a foundation he's had to be such a nice human being. I wouldn't even know what to do if I was in his shoes- my family is the polar opposite of his.
He's so adorable, even when he's nearing 30 he has such a childlike energy to him that's contagious, and I don't mean adorable in the condescending way, I mean that he's so himself in that way, even if he restricts himself in AmazingPhil a bit.
tl;dr Phil should be Willy Wonka and I will fite anyone who disagrees
literally only logged in to post that
-
- morning quiff
- Posts: 466
- Joined: Tue Aug 30, 2016 6:47 pm
- Pronouns: she/her
- Location: post-baking universe
000dia000 wrote:
tl;dr Phil should be Willy Wonka and I will fite anyone who disagrees
^^^^^
literally only logged in to post that
Do we mean... PHILLY WONKA?!
I'm sorry I'll let myself out
I mean c'mon, this sequence just screams Phil, the magician and chocolate whiz
- Kathrynxjane
- janice from the shop
- Posts: 518
- Joined: Sun Mar 27, 2016 7:31 am
- Pronouns: She/Her
- Location: Birmingham, England
That is freaking adorable!bluebox-away wrote:I'm a couple pages behind, so not much to contribute as of right now apart from Martyn posted a cute instagram with Phil and Kath with the caption "Perfectly normal family". Also it's geotagged as York, so the wedding is there not IoM
"You can't just pull it out and put it in without a plan." Dan Howell 2015
- bluebox-away
- woodland creature
- Posts: 588
- Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 11:28 pm
- Pronouns: she/her
- Location: London, England
Yep that is distinctly a twin room, so Phil and Martyn sharing and Dan most definitely in London Also, re family, I think it's easy to assume that Dan has a rough relationship with his family simply because it's presented right next to Phil's picture perfect happy family? Cause obviously Phil really loves his family and they spend a lot of time together, but a lot of people have a less-great relationship than that with their parents but are still absolutely fine? To be honest, based on what we know of Dan, if his family truly disliked Phil then I would think he'd just never go homeMoonPride wrote:Looks like Martyn went without Cornelia and shared a hotel room with Phil. I'd insert the photo from Martyn's Twitter but I have no clue how to do that on my phone.
The results of Eevee's survey will be interesting to see, I would've maybe added a location question though to compare what people around the world think? Idk. Generally I would say you'd only spend a full christmas few days with one person's family once you're longterm/married and/or have children? If you're single you go home unless you have specific other plans, if you're only just dating you'll maybe do one of christmas eve / day at each set of parents..
06/04/2016 - I found The Weakest Link
Gif credit: IckleMissMayhem
- papierklemmen
- flower crown
- Posts: 732
- Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2016 11:04 am
Ugh, you just reminded me of that time when someone asked Martyn whether deppy are dating in the tatinof merch line (i think).melon lord wrote:I actually really like how Kath and Martyn/Cornelia are all universally loved and cherished within the fandom It would be terrifying exposing your family and not knowing the outcome of it, but I'm happy that everyone is treated well and for the most part, respectfully (I mean that as in people trying to get answers out of Martyn/Cornelia or stuff like that)
Phil has such a wonderful family and it really shows how strong of a foundation he's had to be such a nice human being. I wouldn't even know what to do if I was in his shoes- my family is the polar opposite of his.
He's so adorable, even when he's nearing 30 he has such a childlike energy to him that's contagious, and I don't mean adorable in the condescending way, I mean that he's so himself in that way, even if he restricts himself in AmazingPhil a bit.
tl;dr Phil should be Willy Wonka and I will fite anyone who disagrees
I REALLY hope it doesn't happen often, but the scary part is we don't know, what if they run into crazy deppy fangirls on a daily basis...
Thank you for your thoughtful and insightful post. It made me think about “gamingmas” in a new light. I value this forum as a place for both light hearted and serious discussion between individuals with different perspectives.fancybum wrote:
I do see the opposing point that context and individual intent can change a word from hurtful to neutral to empowering, however I also support an individual’s right to choose how they are labelled. In the case of you using a word to refer to yourself or your friends, you know how those individuals feel about that label. We do not have the same certainty with Dan and Phil.
People are free to use idb to discuss about whatever topics they wish, including social and moral issues relating to use of language around sexuality and gender. There seems to be a problem here with you telling other posters what views they should and should not express, for example telling fancybum to “suck it up and stop whining”, when they were completely within the rules.eevee wrote:I agree with your whole post but I'm quoting this part because it's totally what I was trying to get at, thanks for putting it into words!jesuisunèléve wrote: That being said, these forums are not a place for social commentary on what is or is not appropriate. We are a selective audience, and there are rules in place. We can't take ourselves too seriously on here, to be honest, because we are gossiping about two bros (lol) who have created this path for themselves (I think this has been said?) and it's fun and light-hearted.
Please note: I am posting in a personal capacity and not on behalf of moderators.
-
- moon room
- Posts: 439
- Joined: Sun Mar 27, 2016 9:26 am
I'm the first that when I had serious problems with something here didn't speak up but ignored it, in part because I don't care to argue online in part because idb for me is a hobby, a distraction from real life, so I don't wanna be too hard on some topics in a forum like this. At the same time because I am human and complicated, I like to read people post something more related to social and moral issues,what made me like the old site were some throughtful post like that. To hear a different approch to an issue (always if in a respectful way), even if I disagree with i it, is good.BisexualShoeMarriage wrote:People are free to use idb to discuss about whatever topics they wish, including social and moral issues relating to use of language around sexuality and gender. There seems to be a problem here with you telling other posters what views they should and should not express, for example telling fancybum to “suck it up and stop whining”, when they were completely within the rules.eevee wrote:I agree with your whole post but I'm quoting this part because it's totally what I was trying to get at, thanks for putting it into words!jesuisunèléve wrote: That being said, these forums are not a place for social commentary on what is or is not appropriate. We are a selective audience, and there are rules in place. We can't take ourselves too seriously on here, to be honest, because we are gossiping about two bros (lol) who have created this path for themselves (I think this has been said?) and it's fun and light-hearted.
Please note: I am posting in a personal capacity and not on behalf of moderators.
P.S. that's my opinion, it's not against anyone
Now ... tommorow is dan's ls? just checking because I don't remember anymore when they do, when was the last one... :
edit: louise tweet, what is it about?
Last edited by corn flakes on Mon Dec 12, 2016 1:39 pm, edited 1 time in total.
English is not my first language: half of the mistakes are typos ,half are me