I have to say I really love this discussion y'all. It's been a fascinating read to wake up to.
LtrllySusan wrote: Sun Sep 02, 2018 6:03 am
D&P have the most carefully crafted interactions with fans online that I've seen. It's like they live in this castle and every once in a while they get on the balcony to wave at us peasants (and we get very excited), but aside from that, they pull the curtains shut and would rather ignore the angry mob than give up their personas.
 
I have never heard a more accurate description of our relationship with Dan and Phil. It's interesting, when you consider how many people praise them for their fan engagement. And it's not like they don't regularly engage, but it's all shallow and it's all jokes. Once you hit the serious stuff, the curtains come RIGHT down.
dancy wrote: Sun Sep 02, 2018 12:22 pm
People absolutely have the right to be upset, especially if it somehow messes with their plans and makes it unable or more inconvenient for them to go. I'm sure this isn't easy for D&P either and that they made the best possible decision. They're not to blame but like most of you said, communication is and has always been a problem with these two. Every time something like this happens, I hope they take something away from it and do better the next time around but nope. It's basically the same as what happened with Montreal: Phil writing a not-so-great tweet, Dan completely ignoring the issue (online, that is), no announcements on other social media platforms besides Twitter, disappearing when people have questions etc. It's a mess and they would really benefit from having a PR assistant in these types of situations, someone to give them good advice and who they'll actually listen to. I'm afraid this will happen again with the TBC dates and it's just a shame because the way you deliver news and deal with a situation can alleviate it, even if the actual problem itself can't be changed. Sigh, I hope things will work out for most people.
 
I could not agree more with this and it's exactly what I wanted to say. A lot of "I hope they learn from this" happening, but when have they ever? Frankly, it's strange that they continue to recycle the same format of non-apologies and it makes me wonder if they perhaps think it works. Like, realistically, what do they lose from this? Fans being mad for a couple days and then it all blows over with a couple of cute online interactions.
I recognize that I'll probably end up a hypocrite here who gets over the frustration of this situation, but as it stands, even Dan's instagram stories today felt  oddly fake and like a bit of a distraction. I feel like the whole angry over coffee bit is not something Dan would have ever posted if they weren't trying to recover from the Manila situation a bit (and are probably still short  a gaming video). Maybe that's a very negative outlook, but that's what I'm rockin' right now.
LtrllySusan wrote: Sun Sep 02, 2018 9:39 am
Yes, it's probably not their fault, but a "hopefully you can all reschedule and have spare money smiley-face" and an (implied) "be glad you get anything at all" attitude isn't the best way to go. Let's quickly drop some cute insta stories and a video later and people won't be upset anymore?
 
I'm just quoting this because YES, preach, amen, etc.
alittledizzy wrote: Sun Sep 02, 2018 5:12 am
I think the problem with Dan handling something like that is that he's compassionate when he's allowed to address an issue that maybe has some emotional resonance with him but he is shit at dealing with things that are issues fans are upset about that have to do directly with action or behavior from himself and Phil. I'm far more inclined to think that Dan handling this with be in the same vein as Dan's attitude toward that week in March, or fans wanting to know about the Bahamas thing, or the June video, or in general just his channel right now. I think that he doesn't have much patience with the limited scope of view fans have (not that it's our fault we don't have the insight into situations they have) and he gets defensive and snippy and, in his worst moments, downright resentful that we're even expressing anger over something that he thinks we should either be patient on or more understanding about. So yeah I feel like they go with Phil for exactly that reason; because running more on an emotional wavelength cuts both ways and that would absolutely not go over well in a situation like this.
 
I mostly agree with you that there are pros and cons to Dan dealing with this sort of thing, but I don't think he needs to write an essay or film a video. At minimum, a retweet would suffice. He doesn't even need to respond to replies. (After all, it's not like Phil is...) Literally any level of acknowledgment would be better than none. 
Frankly, it's a little pathetic. He's half the face of this tour and he hasn't once helped communicate information regarding changes. I genuinely just don't get him sometimes. If he thinks avoiding conflict keeps his image clean, I think it does the opposite.... I'm literally just making myself frustrated here.
All in all, I feel like this situation really highlights their biggest weaknesses. At some point, your fandom and engagement is not going to be rainbows and butterflies and I feel like you can't just rely on that eventual outcome forever.